Toggle menu
Customer Service:
M-F:
269-742-4716
8:00am-4:30pm EST
Compare
Gift Certificates
My Account
Checkout
Sign in
or
Create an account
Search
Search
2020 Coins
2019 Coins
Reject & Problem Coins
All Reject & Problem Coins
Nickels
Featured Coins
All Featured Coins
Half Cents
Large Cents
Cents
Two Cents
Three Cents
Nickels
Dimes
Twenty Cents
Quarters
Halves
Dollars
Silver Eagles
Coin Runs
All Coin Runs
Proof Sets
Quarter Runs
Mint Sets
Presidential
Cents
Nickels
Dimes
Quarters
Halves
Dollars
Proof Sets
All Proof Sets
American Legacy
Clad
Limited Edition
Silver
Clad Quarter
No Box
OGP
Silver Quarter
No Box
OGP
Presidential
No Box
OGP
Partial
Clad
Silver
Birth Year
Happy Birthday
Prestige
OGP
10 Pack
Mint Sets
All Mint Sets
Bicentennial
Full
Special
OGP
ATB Parks
Partial
Original Box
Enhanced
10 Pack
Half Cents
Cents
All Cents
Shield
Uncirculated
Proof
Satin
Cello
Enhanced BU
Rolls
Bicentennial
Uncirculated
Proof
Cello
Satin
Rolls
Memorial
Lot
Uncirculated
Proof
Satin
Cello
Rolls
Wheat
Circulated
Uncirculated
Proof
Rolls
Lot
Indian Head
Circulated
Lot
Flying Eagle
Circulated
Year Set
Large Cents
All Large Cents
Braided Hair
Flowing Hair
Two Cents
Three Cents
All Three Cents
Nickel
Silver
Nickels
All Nickels
Jefferson
Proof
Uncirculated
Cello
Satin
Circulated
Rolls
Lot
Buffalo
Circulated
Uncirculated
Lot
Liberty V
Uncirculated
Circulated
Lot
Year Set
Dimes
All Dimes
Roosevelt
Clad Proof
Silver Proof
Uncirculated
Satin
Cello
Circulated
Rolls
Year Set
Seated Half Dime
Mercury
Uncirculated
Circulated
Barber
Circulated
Lot
Uncirculated
Year Set
Rejects
Quarters
All Quarters
ATB Parks
Clad Proof
Proof
Silver Proof
Uncirculated
Satin
Rolls
Lot
Territory
Clad Proof
Silver Proof
Uncirculated
Satin
State
Clad Proof
Rolls
Run
Silver Proof
Uncirculated
Satin
Washington
Clad Proof
Silver Proof
Uncirculated
Circulated
Cello
Rolls
Standing
Circulated
Rolls
Barber
Circulated
Rolls
Seated Liberty
Year Set
Rejects
Halves
All Halves
Kennedy
Clad Proof
Silver Proof
Uncirculated
Circulated
Satin
Cello
Rolls
Franklin
Lot
Silver Proof
Uncirculated
Circulated
Cello
Rolls
Walking Liberty
Rolls
Uncirculated
Circulated
Barber
Circulated
Rolls
Seated
Circulated
Capped Bust
Circulated
Year Set
Commem
Circulated
OGP
Rolls
Set
Proof
BU
Dollars
All Dollars
Innovation
Uncirculated
Proof
Set
Rolls
Presidential
Uncirculated
Proof
Satin
Cello
Lot
Native
Uncirculated
Proof
Cello
Satin
Enhanced BU
Rolls
Susan B
Circulated
Uncirculated
Proof
Cello
Sets
Rolls
Eisenhower
Lot
Proof
Uncirculated
Circulated
Cello
Rolls
Peace
Circulated
Uncirculated
Morgan
Circulated
Uncirculated
Silver Eagles
BU
Proof
Year Set
Commem
BU
Proof
Set
Rolls
Rejects
Supplies
All Supplies
Coin Flips
Coin Tubes
Storage Bags
Tape
Equipment
Shipping Supplies
Empty Packaging
All Empty Packaging
Proof Set Packaging
Silver Proof Set Packaging
Quarter Proof Set Packaging
Silver Quarter Set Packaging
Presidential Dollar Packaging
Lenses With Inserts
World Coins
All World Coins
Canada
About Us
Dave in the News
Contact Us
Shipping & Return
Privacy
Articles
Glossary
Testimonials
Gift Certificates
Sign in
or
Register
Search Keyword:
Search
About Us
Dave in the News
Contact Us
Shipping & Return
Privacy
Articles
Glossary
Testimonials
0
Categories
2020 Coins
2019 Coins
Reject & Problem Coins
Nickels
Featured Coins
Half Cents
Large Cents
Cents
Two Cents
Three Cents
Nickels
Dimes
Twenty Cents
Quarters
Halves
Dollars
Silver Eagles
Coin Runs
Proof Sets
Quarter Runs
Mint Sets
Presidential
Cents
Nickels
Dimes
Quarters
Halves
Dollars
Proof Sets
American Legacy
Clad
Limited Edition
Silver
Clad Quarter
Silver Quarter
Presidential
Partial
Birth Year
Happy Birthday
Prestige
10 Pack
Mint Sets
Bicentennial
Full
Special
ATB Parks
Partial
Original Box
Enhanced
10 Pack
Half Cents
Cents
Shield
Bicentennial
Memorial
Wheat
Indian Head
Flying Eagle
Year Set
Large Cents
Braided Hair
Flowing Hair
Two Cents
Three Cents
Nickel
Silver
Nickels
Jefferson
Buffalo
Liberty V
Year Set
Dimes
Roosevelt
Seated Half Dime
Mercury
Barber
Year Set
Rejects
Quarters
ATB Parks
Territory
State
Washington
Standing
Barber
Seated Liberty
Year Set
Rejects
Halves
Kennedy
Franklin
Walking Liberty
Barber
Seated
Capped Bust
Year Set
Commem
Dollars
Innovation
Presidential
Native
Susan B
Eisenhower
Peace
Morgan
Silver Eagles
Year Set
Commem
Rejects
Supplies
Coin Flips
Coin Tubes
Storage Bags
Tape
Equipment
Shipping Supplies
Empty Packaging
Proof Set Packaging
Silver Proof Set Packaging
Quarter Proof Set Packaging
Silver Quarter Set Packaging
Presidential Dollar Packaging
Lenses With Inserts
World Coins
Canada
Home
Nickels
Buffalo
Buffalo
Circulated
Uncirculated
Lot
Sort By:
Featured Items
Newest Items
Best Selling
A to Z
Z to A
By Review
Price: Ascending
Price: Descending
1
2
3
Next
1867 Shield Nickel Filler Readable Date See Photos C681
$13.95
$11.54
Add to Cart
1867 Shield Nickel No Rays Filler Readable Date See Photos C681
$10.45
$8.56
Add to Cart
1868 Shield Nickel Dark Hard To Read See Photos C738
$8.45
$7.05
Add to Cart
1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 Raised Mound Fine FN
$24.95
$20.68
Add to Cart
1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 Raised Mound Fine FN See Photos C586
$26.95
$22.13
Add to Cart
1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 Raised Mound Good GD
$19.45
$15.95
Add to Cart
1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 Raised Mound Very Good VG
$23.95
$19.23
Add to Cart
1913 D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Line Good Weak Date See Photos B689
$149.95
$124.83
Add to Cart
1913 D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Line Very Good VG+ See Photos B921
$229.95
$191.69
Add to Cart
1913 S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Line About Good AG See Photos B555
$189.95
$156.89
Add to Cart
1914 Buffalo Nickel About Good AG
$15.95
$13.01
Add to Cart
1914 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$24.95
$20.68
Add to Cart
1914 S Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$54.95
$43.17
Add to Cart
1915 Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$9.95
$8.11
Add to Cart
1915 D Buffalo Nickel Very Good Obverse Scratch See Photos C755
$27.95
$23.22
Add to Cart
1915 S Buffalo Nickel Fair Hard to Read Date Filler See Photos C739
$30.95
$25.38
Add to Cart
1916 Buffalo Nickel About Good AG
$2.55
$2.05
Add to Cart
1916 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$5.95
$4.77
Add to Cart
1916 Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$9.95
$8.18
Add to Cart
1917 Buffalo Nickel About Good AG
$2.55
$2.13
Add to Cart
1917 Buffalo Nickel Fine FN
$14.95
$12.20
Add to Cart
1917 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$6.45
$5.16
Add to Cart
1917 Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$10.45
$8.33
Add to Cart
1918 Buffalo Nickel About Good AG
$2.95
$2.45
Add to Cart
1918 Buffalo Nickel Fine FN
$11.95
$9.75
Add to Cart
1918 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$6.45
$5.08
Add to Cart
1918 Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$8.95
$7.20
Add to Cart
1919 Buffalo Nickel About Good AG
$1.65
$1.32
Add to Cart
1919 Buffalo Nickel Fine FN
$7.45
$5.99
Add to Cart
1919 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$3.45
$2.84
Add to Cart
1919 Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$5.45
$4.54
Add to Cart
1920 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$2.25
$1.81
Add to Cart
1921 Buffalo Nickel Fine FN
$11.45
$9.30
Add to Cart
1921 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$5.45
$4.31
Add to Cart
1921 Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$9.95
$8.03
Add to Cart
1923 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$2.15
$1.73
Add to Cart
1923 S Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$11.95
$9.98
Add to Cart
1924 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$1.95
$1.57
Add to Cart
1924 Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$5.45
$4.54
Add to Cart
1925 Buffalo Nickel About Good AG
$1.45
$1.18
Add to Cart
1925 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$2.35
$1.92
Add to Cart
1925 Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$4.55
$3.77
Add to Cart
1926 Buffalo Nickel Fine FN
$4.15
$3.39
Add to Cart
1926 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$1.95
$1.57
Add to Cart
1926 Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$2.55
$2.05
Add to Cart
1927 Buffalo Nickel Fine FN
$3.45
$2.84
Add to Cart
1927 Buffalo Nickel Good GD
$1.85
$1.49
Add to Cart
1927 Buffalo Nickel Very Good VG
$2.15
$1.76
Add to Cart
1
2
3
Next
×
